Georgia’s abortion ban counts a fetus as an individual. And now, so does its tax code.
The state’s Division of Income introduced this week that “any unborn baby with a detectable human heartbeat” may be claimed as dependent, offering a $3,000 tax exemption for every being pregnant inside a family, months earlier than the kid is born. Georgia’s law bans most abortions after six weeks, which is normally round when medical doctors can start to detect fetal cardiac exercise.
The announcement marks a brand new frontier of anti-abortion policymaking in a post-Roe America, the place conservative lawmakers have moved past banning abortion, and at the moment are attempting to increase the authorized rights and protections afforded to a fetus below “fetal personhood” legal guidelines. Georgia, Alabama and Arizona have handed abortion bans that embrace language broadly defining a fetus as an individual.
Individually, practically 40 states, together with Texas and California, outline a fetus as an individual in instances involving murder. For instance, Scott Peterson in 2004 was convicted in California of murdering his wife and unborn child. His spouse, Laci Peterson, was eight months pregnant when she was killed.
Georgia’s abortion regulation goes additional than another fetal personhood provision. Known as the Residing Infants Equity and Equality, or LIFE, Act, it prohibits abortion after six weeks and explicitly acknowledges the fetus as an individual.
A federal choose struck down the laws final summer season, discovering that it violated a girl’s constitutional proper to an abortion. The appeals courtroom delayed a closing determination, pending a ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court docket.
Extra Protection of the Kansas Abortion Vote
After the Supreme Court docket overturned Roe v. Wade on June 24, a three-judge panel from the U.S. Court docket of Appeals for the eleventh Circuit handed Georgia conservatives their long-anticipated victory, permitting the abortion restrictions to take impact.
Within the appeals courtroom’s July 20 ruling, Chief Choose William H. Pryor Jr. wrote that “an individual of cheap intelligence is able to understanding that the ‘core which means [of]’ the supply is to increase the definition of individual to incorporate unborn people who’re carried within the womb of their mom at any stage of improvement.”
Gov. Brian Kemp, who signed the regulation in 2019, celebrated the courtroom’s determination.
“Georgia is a state that values and helps life in any respect levels — and the Georgia LIFE Act and this provision each replicate that dedication,” mentioned a spokesman for Mr. Kemp.
State Consultant Ed Setzler, a Republican sponsor of the regulation, mentioned in a leaked 2019 video that the last word aim of the regulation is to have the Supreme Court docket acknowledge the personhood of a fetus.
“It’s about establishing personhood of the unborn baby, within the tax code, for baby help for moms, in our census counts, throughout our code, in order that we will lay the inspiration that no different state within the nation within the final 46 years has ever carried out, which is to ascertain the personhood of this baby, and we’re going to take this to the best courtroom within the land,” Mr. Setzler mentioned within the video.
Mr. Setzler didn’t reply to requests for remark.
Georgia’s push to acknowledge a fetus as an individual may lay the blueprint for different conservative states, which haven’t but clarified the which means and results of such an strategy, authorized consultants mentioned.
“The anti-abortion motion has all the time been a personhood motion, there was simply no consensus on what that truly meant,” mentioned Mary Ziegler, a regulation professor on the College of California, Davis, who has written a number of books on abortion and the regulation.
Earlier than the demise of Roe, conservatives had been united across the singular aim of proscribing abortion entry. However Ms. Ziegler says the anti-abortion motion is struggling to search out consensus on what fetal personhood means in a post-Roe authorized panorama.
“No one has actually labored out, how do you implement personhood past simply ‘you’ll be able to’t have an abortion,’” she mentioned. “Georgia is beginning to work that out, however they’ve actually solely checked out a handful of conditions. How do you implement this in HOV lanes? Do you give a fetus its personal lawyer? There are such a lot of questions left open.”
Final month, a pregnant Texas woman ticketed for riding in the HOV lane alone argued that her fetus counted as an individual below the state’s abortion ban. Texas’ abortion ban doesn’t included fetal personhood, however its penal code does.
Georgia’s abortion regulation additionally permits the mom to gather baby help to cowl the price of “direct medical and being pregnant associated bills” earlier than the kid is born.
Democrats mentioned the regulation may additionally expose girls who expertise miscarriages to unknown penalties.
“So what occurs if you declare your fetus as a dependent after which miscarry later within the being pregnant, you get investigated each for tax fraud and an unlawful abortion?” tweeted Lauren Groh-Wargo, the marketing campaign supervisor of the Democratic candidate for governor of Georgia, Stacey Abrams.
Monday’s announcement says taxpayers who declare the brand new deduction could also be requested to offer medical information or documentation of the being pregnant. The Income Division has not clarified if and the way households who lose a being pregnant would possibly defend themselves from allegations of fraud.
Particular directions on how one can declare a fetus on a tax return are anticipated later this 12 months.